analyst.andrewlengly.com/studies/tiktok-stem-feed :: tiktok stem feed
# Why TikTok’s US STEM feed trails Douyin. The STEM tab drew 0.84 views per reached user a year against about 959 science views per Douyin user. A data study by Andrew Leng Ly.
designed page ......... analyst.andrewlengly.com/studies/tiktok-stem-feed
TIKTOK STEM FEED
analyst work .......... /machine/analyst data study ............ October 2026 question .............. Why does TikTok’s US STEM feed trail Douyin in China, and what would make it work? headline finding ...... Douyin users each watched about 959 science videos in a year. TikTok’s STEM tab drew 0.84 views a year for each user it reached, less than one video each. The two counts cover different scopes. My reading is that where the feed sits and how teen limits are enforced drive the gap. my recommendation ..... Make a capped teen mode the home screen for verified teens, and pay for more STEM videos to fill it. Speed up review and publish the minutes moved into STEM. tools ................. CSV tables with a source URL on every row · JavaScript on Node for the derived rates · D3.js for the first dashboard · React and SVG for the charts on this page
THE QUESTION
the client ............ The team that runs TikTok’s STEM feed in the US. TikTok announced the feed in March 2023, and in January 2026 the TikTok USDS Joint Venture was formed to run and retrain the US algorithm. the decision they face What should change so the feed reaches US teens? The candidates were where the feed sits, how teen settings are enforced, how much STEM content exists and how success gets measured.
THE DATA, 3 TABLES
[01] metrics.csv ................................................................... 37 rows /studies/tiktok-stem-feed/data/metrics.csv Every figure on TikTok’s STEM feed, Douyin’s science content, teen use and time limits. Each row has its market, period, scope and a flag for whether the platform reported it. where it came from Press coverage of TikTok and Douyin announcements, TikTok Newsroom, Pew Research Center, a CMMR survey reported by Gigazine and press reports of the Kentucky attorney general’s filing. why i chose it ... Each figure gets an ID and a scope, so a count for one tab can’t pass for a count across the whole app. what it cannot tell us A like-for-like rate. TikTok publishes no yearly For You STEM views. 22 of the 37 figures come from the platforms themselves, and 8 rows reach the table through a second outlet. [02] events.csv .................................................................... 14 rows /studies/tiktok-stem-feed/data/events.csv Dated events from 2021 to 2026 on China’s minor-protection rules, Douyin’s youth mode, TikTok’s STEM feed and what US lawmakers and courts did about teen use. where it came from Press coverage, plus TikTok’s own newsroom. why i chose it ... The launch and report dates set the window behind finding 1, and the Texas law near the end is what option A rests on. what it cannot tell us Cause. TikTok announced the feed 9 days before its CEO’s House hearing, and the dates alone can’t say why. 3 of the rows are dated to the month. [03] variables.csv .................................................................. 9 rows /studies/tiktok-stem-feed/data/variables.csv Policy and product variables compared across Douyin and TikTok US, each scored 0 to 2 for how far it pushes users toward science content by default. where it came from My own coding, with the row IDs or source names each score rests on. why i chose it ... Each option targets one of the gaps in this table. what it cannot tell us Stand as measurement. The scores are judgment. 7 of the 25 citations in the evidence column name a source with no row in the other two files, so a reader can’t open them from the data.
THE PROCESS
[01] One row per figure
Each figure and each event went into a row of its own with a source name and a URL.
Metric rows also carry a market, a period, a scope and a flag for whether the platform
reported the number. That came to 60 rows across 3 files.
[02] Scope
TikTok’s count covers the STEM tab alone. Douyin’s covers science views anywhere in the
app. I kept both and put the scope on every row, so the mismatch stays visible wherever
the two numbers meet.
[03] Join
TikTok gave its 200 million tab views as a running total. I joined the launch and
report dates in events.csv (rows E05 and E11) to get a window, stored it as 19 months
in row T14 and annualized the views over it.
[04] Assumptions
Views spread evenly across the window. The window starts on March 14, 2023, the day
TikTok announced the feed. Douyin’s monthly users from Feb 2024 stand in for its whole
year of views. The age band that ends at 19 includes two years of adults.
[05] Coding
I scored 9 variables from 0 to 2 for each platform, where 2 pushes users toward science
content by default. The gap is Douyin’s score minus TikTok’s. This table is judgment.
[06] Check
I added three checks after the dashboard was done. Douyin’s daily figure times 365
comes out 0.015% under its yearly figure. The launch and report dates sit 589 days
apart, which is 19.4 months against the 19 I stored, and the exact window moves the tab
rate from 0.84 to 0.83. The third check splits the coding table’s evidence column and
is shown below.
# Three evidence cells before and after the split.
- Before, three rows of variables.csv (four of six columns shown)
- After, one entry per variable
One cell can mix row IDs with source names. After the split, a citation that matches a row
ID lands in “rows”. Any other citation is a name, flagged by whether some row cites that
source. 16 of the 25 citations are row IDs.
# The code for the key steps
- The rate behind finding 1, for the STEM tab and for Douyin.
derive.mjs ........ /studies/tiktok-stem-feed/derive.mjs
- The split of the coding table’s evidence column into row IDs and source names.
derive.mjs ........ /studies/tiktok-stem-feed/derive.mjs
# Dead ends
no yearly for you figure
TikTok does not publish yearly For You STEM views, so I could not
set an all-feed TikTok year beside Douyin’s yearly count. The
closest figure is 110 billion hashtag views counted up to the tab’s
launch with no start date. Finding 1 uses the tab alone.
a mixed denominator
The 200 million views cover the US, UK and Ireland up to the report
date. The 150 million users reached come from a later statement
about Europe and the Americas. The tables hold no user count for the
same markets and dates, so the tab rate divides one scope by
another.
sources with no row
9 citations in the coding table are source names where the rest are
row IDs, and 7 of those names match no row in the other two files. I
have not added rows for them, so those scores can’t be traced from
the data on this page.THE 3 FINDINGS THAT CHANGE THE DECISION
[01] 0.84 · STEM tab views a year for each user it reached, against about 959 per Douyin
user
TikTok’s STEM tab drew 0.84 views a year for each user it reached, and Douyin users
each watched about 959 science videos across the whole app.
dataset .......... metrics.csv
query ............ derive.mjs, reach()
# The STEM tab drew 0.84 views a year for each user it reached
The scopes differ. Douyin’s bar counts science views anywhere in the app, divided by
monthly users. TikTok’s counts the tab alone, divided by users the tab reached and
annualized over 19 months. TikTok publishes no yearly For You STEM views.
Platform and scope .................................... Science views per user per year
TikTok STEM tab, feed only ....................................................... 0.84
Views: 200 million in 19 months · Divided by: 150 million users reached · Sources:
TechCrunch and Eastleigh Voice
Douyin natural science, all feeds .............................................. 958.81
Views: 723.9 billion in a year · Divided by: 755 million monthly users · Sources:
Xinhua (Douyin 2024 Natural Science Report) and Statista via RSIS review
source ........... metrics.csv, derive.mjs, reach()
[02] 4.5% · Douyin users aged 4 to 19, CMMR survey, 2021
Users aged 19 or under were 4.5% of Douyin’s audience in 2021. Youth mode serves only a
small slice of the people behind its 723.9 billion science views.
dataset .......... metrics.csv
query ............ derive.mjs, audience()
# Users aged 19 or under are 4.5% of Douyin’s audience
CMMR survey figures for 2021, reported by Gigazine. Youth mode locks in verified users
under 14, who sit inside the first two bars. The third bar is what remains after those
two.
Age band .................................................... Share of Douyin users (%)
Aged 4 to 12 .................................................................... 0.34%
Where it comes from: Row D14, CMMR survey
Aged 13 to 19 ................................................................... 4.18%
Where it comes from: Row D15, CMMR survey
Everyone else .................................................................. 95.48%
Where it comes from: 100 minus rows D14 and D15
source ........... metrics.csv, derive.mjs, audience()
[03] 1.4% · Drop in teen minutes a day, 108.5 to 107
TikTok’s 60-minute prompt cut average teen use from 108.5 to 107 minutes a day, a 1.4%
drop, while Douyin locks verified under-14s out at 40 minutes.
dataset .......... metrics.csv
query ............ derive.mjs, limitsCalc()
# The 60-minute prompt cut teen use by 1.4%
The two averages come from a TikTok internal test described in the Kentucky attorney
general’s filing. The two limits are settings, shown for scale. The filing says TikTok
planned to revisit the design if use fell by more than 10%.
Measure ............................................................... Minutes per day
Teen average before the prompt .................................................. 108.5
What it is: Measured in TikTok’s internal test · Source: Kentucky AG filing via
NPR/AP
Teen average with the prompt .................................................... 107.0
What it is: Measured in TikTok’s internal test · Source: Kentucky AG filing via
NPR/AP
TikTok’s default limit, under 18 ................................................. 60.0
What it is: A setting that a passcode extends · Source: Engadget
Douyin’s youth-mode cap, under 14 ................................................ 40.0
What it is: A setting the user cannot lift · Source: Engadget / Bloomberg
source ........... metrics.csv, derive.mjs, limitsCalc(), derive.mjs, limitsRows()MY RECOMMENDATION
Give verified teens a capped STEM home screen, and publish how many minutes it moves into STEM. [A] Verified teen mode as the home screen Use the age category that app stores pass to developers under Texas’s App Store Accountability Act. Verified teens land on a curated mode with a hard daily cap that needs a parent to lift. evidence ......... Finding 3. A prompt teens can extend with a passcode cut teen use 1.4%, and Douyin holds verified under-14s to 40 minutes. On my 0-to-2 scale for a hard cap, Douyin scores 2 and TikTok scores 0. main risk ........ The Texas law took effect in January 2026 while under appeal. If the appeal succeeds, the verified age signal goes with it. [B] Pay for more STEM videos Add a STEM multiplier to creator payouts and give verified accounts to US museums and universities. evidence ......... Douyin reports 856 verified museum accounts and 101 academicians presenting through science museums. TikTok reports 7,000 STEM creators worldwide and no count of institutions. main risk ........ Supply may not be what holds the tab back. TikTok counts almost 15 million STEM videos published in the 3 years to Feb 2025, and the tab still drew 0.84 views a year for each user it reached. [C] Speed up review Pre-approve credentialed creators so their uploads skip the two-partner review queue, with spot checks after posting. evidence ......... Every STEM feed video has to pass review by Common Sense Networks and Poynter, and Douyin’s reviewers curate a youth pool of 543,600 videos. main risk ........ Review is the one factor I scored the same for both platforms, 1 and 1 on my 0-to-2 scale. By my own scoring, faster review closes no gap. [D] Change the scorecard Measure minutes moved into STEM content and publish the figure. evidence ......... Finding 3. The Kentucky filing describes TikTok judging its teen time tools by press coverage and public trust. main risk ........ TikTok would report the figure itself. 10 of the 21 TikTok figures in this study already come from the company. - The teen mode puts verified teens on a home screen with a daily cap only a parent can lift. - Paying for STEM videos fills that screen. Faster review lets credentialed creators post sooner, though by my own scoring it closes no gap on its own. - The scorecard tells TikTok whether any of it works. Today it judges its teen time tools by press coverage.
LIMITS AND NEXT STEPS
# What the data cannot support
- The two rates in finding 1 cover different scopes. Douyin’s counts science views
anywhere in the app and TikTok’s counts one tab.
- The TikTok rate divides views in the US, UK and Ireland by users reached across Europe
and the Americas, from two statements made at different times.
- 22 of the 37 metrics come from the platforms themselves. 8 rows cite their source
through a second outlet, among them the Kentucky filing and the CMMR survey.
- Douyin’s age split dates from 2021 and its youth-mode pool size from 2020.
- “Trails” means the tab fell short of Douyin’s reach. TikTok’s own figures for the tab
read well, with 25% of visitors back the next day and 96% viewer satisfaction (rows T03,
T04).
- Nothing here follows one teen from the tab to a science video. Placement and enforcement
are my reading of platform totals and a table I coded by hand.
# What I would test with more access
- With TikTok’s Research API I would pull view counts by hashtag and year, which would put
a For You figure beside Douyin’s.
- I would pull Google Trends search interest in “TikTok STEM” as a signal of demand.
- With TikTok’s own data I would measure minutes moved into STEM content per teen, the
number option D asks TikTok to publish.
- I would add a row and a URL for every source the coding table names, and read the
Kentucky filing itself.TL;DR
studied ............... How TikTok’s US STEM feed compares with Douyin’s science content, and what would close the gap. found ................. TikTok’s STEM tab drew 0.84 views a year for each user it reached, against about 959 science views per Douyin user. # by the numbers 0.84 ................ STEM tab views a year per user reached 4.5% ................ Douyin users aged 4 to 19, 2021 1.4% ................ Drop in teen minutes from the 60-minute prompt the catch ............. The two rates cover different scopes. Douyin’s counts the whole app, and TikTok’s counts one tab. next .................. With TikTok’s Research API, pull view counts by hashtag and year to set a For You figure beside Douyin’s.
# end of /machine/tiktok-stem-feed. andrew.leng.ly@gmail.com · leave machine mode