Skip to content

andrewlengly.com/skills-hiring-casestudy :: skills-based hiring case study

# How many jobs ask for a degree their own workers don’t hold, and what Greenhouse should build so employers hire on skills.

designed page ......... /skills-hiring-casestudy

THE SHORT VERSION

  A data study of how many jobs ask for a degree their own workers do not hold, across 177
  occupations that list a bachelor's degree. It joins BLS data to O*NET's worker surveys and
  builds a launch list of ten roles. Built with Python, pandas, DuckDB and Excel, it
  recommends skills-first job templates shipped together with built-in assessments.

the question .......... Employers keep announcing they’ve dropped degree requirements. Why
                        has so little changed in who they hire, and what can an ATS do about
                        it?
what i did ............ Joined BLS data on 177 bachelor’s-listed occupations to O*NET’s
                        worker surveys, sized the openings, and built a launch list of ten
                        roles.
where it stands ....... Done in November 2026. I recommend skills-first job templates
                        shipped together with built-in assessments.

kind .................. Case study · Data study
role .................. Analyst
year .................. 2026
tools ................. Python, pandas, DuckDB, Jupyter, Excel, O*NET

the question .......... How many jobs list a degree their own workers don’t hold, and what
                        should Greenhouse build about it?

THE QUESTION

  # Companies dropped the degree line. Most kept hiring the same people.

  The Burning Glass Institute and Harvard Business School followed 11,300 roles at large
  firms before and after degree requirements came off the posting. Non-degree hiring rose
  3.5 points on average. That touched fewer than 1 in 700 hires in 2023.

  Greenhouse sits where that decision gets made, in the job post and the screen. So I asked
  where the degree requirement is weakest and what product would make the change stick.
2024 report ........... Skills-Based Hiring: The Long Road from Pronouncements to Practice

HOW I DID IT

  # Two government sources, joined on the occupation code.

  # From BLS and O*NET tables to a launch list
  01. BLS tables
      Typical entry education
      What current workers hold
      Jobs and openings
  02. O*NET
      What workers say the job requires
      Skill importance
  03. Join
      6-digit SOC code
      742 occupations matched
      Detail: O*NET splits some codes into .01 and .02, so values average up to the 6-digit
      code
  04. Size
      Openings times the share without a degree
  05. Shortlist
      Four filters
      Ranked by openings

degree gap ............ the share of workers 25 and older in a bachelor’s-listed job who
                        hold no bachelor’s (BLS Table 5.3)
skills-first openings
                        annual openings times the degree gap
distinctive skill ..... a skill whose importance in this job sits furthest above its average
                        across all jobs (O*NET)
  Generic skills like active listening rank high in nearly every job, so the shortlist shows
  distinctive ones. Those make better assessment targets.

WHAT THE DATA SHOWS

  # In bachelor’s-listed jobs, 3 in 10 workers have no bachelor’s.

occupations listing a bachelor’s
                        177
workers in them without one
                        12.7M
skills-first openings a year
                        970K
bls and o*net agreement
                        0.48

  # No bachelor’s, in bachelor’s-listed jobs with 100,000+ workers
construction managers
                        65%
cost estimators ....... 61%
facilities managers ... 61%
buyers and purchasing agents
                        57%
logisticians .......... 55%
general and operations managers
                        53%
technical sales representatives
                        50%
  BLS Table 5.3, 2023 to 2024. Postsecondary teaching assistants (66%) are left off, since
  schools set their own rules.

  O*NET asks workers what education their job needs. Across bachelor’s-listed occupations,
  the share who say less than a bachelor’s is enough tracks the share who hold less than one
  (correlation 0.48). 30 occupations clear 30% on both.

WHY TEMPLATES NEED TESTS

  # The firms that changed who they hired changed how they judged skill.

  # What firms that dropped degree requirements did next
changed who they hired
                        37%
changed the posting only
                        45%
gained, then slid back
                        18%
source ................ Burning Glass Institute and HBS, 2024

  At the firms that did change, non-degreed hires stayed at a rate 10 points higher than
  their degree-holding colleagues. A 2025 follow-up across 1,000+ employers found that
  removing the requirement alone added about 2 points of non-degree hires.

  The leaders changed how candidates got screened. An assessment built into the ATS is that
  change.

LAUNCH LIST

  # Ten roles to launch with, about 260,000 openings a year.

  # Launch roles ranked by skills-first openings
columns ............... Openings a year | No bachelor’s (BLS) | Say less is needed (O*NET)
general and operations managers
                        285.0K | 53% | 72%
construction managers
                        49.7K | 65% | 55%
technical sales representatives
                        23.6K | 50% | 63%
computer occupations, all other
                        27.0K | 43% | 42%
compliance officers ... 32.7K | 35% | 37%
administrative services managers
                        22.0K | 43% | 72%
facilities managers ... 14.2K | 61% | 54%
industrial production managers
                        17.0K | 50% | 53%
loan officers ......... 17.1K | 46% | 30%
network and computer systems administrators
                        13.4K | 47% | 38%
  Filters: a bachelor’s listed, 30%+ of workers without one, 30%+ saying less is needed,
  5,000+ openings a year. Teaching and clergy roles are left out because licensing boards or
  the employer set those rules.

MY RECOMMENDATION

  # Ship the template and the test together.

skills-first templates
                        List the role’s distinctive skills from O*NET, with the degree field
                        optional by default.
an assessment per template
                        Templates alone repeat what most employers did. The test is what
                        changes the screen.
match the test to the skill
                        Management roles get a budget or staffing case. For technical roles,
                        a hands-on task. Sales candidates do a role play, and compliance
                        candidates write a short memo.
launch with the ten ... About 260,000 skills-first openings a year between them.
show customers the proof
                        Report hires made without a degree and how long they stay, in each
                        customer’s own data.

LIMITS

  # What this data can’t tell you.

older hires ........... Some workers without a degree were hired before the degree became
                        the norm, so the gap may overstate new hiring.
an estimate of scale
                        Openings times a share sizes the opportunity. It doesn’t predict
                        actual hires.
validate the skills ... O*NET ratings come from analysts and workers. Each customer should
                        check assessments against its own top performers.

WHAT’S NEXT

  # What I’d study once templates ship.

an a/b test on posts
                        Compare applicant pools and pass rates for the same role posted with
                        and without the degree line.
assessment validity ... Check whether assessment scores predict 12-month ratings better than
                        the degree did.
adjacent jobs ......... Use O*NET skill overlap to find which current jobs feed each launch
                        role, so recruiters know where to source.
backslide alerts ...... Flag customers whose share of non-degree hires drops after launch,
                        the pattern Burning Glass saw in 18% of firms.
pay outcomes .......... Join BLS wage data to show what a skills-first hire earns against
                        their last job.

TL;DR

studied ............... How many jobs ask for a degree their own workers don’t hold, across
                        177 bachelor’s-listed occupations.
found ................. In bachelor’s-listed jobs, 3 in 10 workers have no bachelor’s, 12.7M
                        people in all.
  # by the numbers
  12.7M ............... Workers without the degree their job lists
  970K ................ Skills-first openings a year
  0.48 ................ BLS and O*NET agreement
the catch ............. Some workers without a degree were hired before it became the norm,
                        so the gap may overstate new hiring.
next .................. A/B test job posts with and without the degree line, and compare the
                        applicant pools.

LINKS

open skills-based hiring
                        /studies/skills-hiring.pdf
the analyst side ...... /machine/analyst

# end of /machine/skills-hiring-casestudy. andrew.leng.ly@gmail.com · leave machine mode