analyst.andrewlengly.com/studies/handshake-and-linkedin :: handshake and linkedin
# How can Handshake win new-grad hiring against LinkedIn and Indeed? Recent graduates are out of work at 5.7% against 4.1% for all workers. A data study by Andrew Leng Ly.
designed page ......... analyst.andrewlengly.com/studies/handshake-and-linkedin
HANDSHAKE AND LINKEDIN
analyst work .......... /machine/analyst data study ............ October 2026 question .............. How can Handshake win new-grad hiring against LinkedIn and Indeed? headline finding ...... Recent graduates were out of work at 5.7% in June 2026, against 4.1% for all workers. Employers on Ashby’s hiring platform now sift 291 applications per hire. In NACE’s spring survey 43.4% of employers had detected AI-written applications and 20.1% used a tool to detect AI help. my recommendation ..... Sell employers a verified applicant channel first. Then add alumni referrals and proof of skill from Handshake AI work on that verified base. tools ................. CSV tables with a source URL on every row · JavaScript on Node for the derived rates · D3.js for the first dashboard · React and SVG for the charts on this page
THE QUESTION
the client ............ Handshake’s leadership. More than 1,600 schools run their career services on Handshake. By press reports, AI training made up 87% of its gross annualized revenue in April 2026. In June 2026 it opened sign-up to any email address and let search engines index student profiles. the decision they face Should Handshake keep opening up into a general network like LinkedIn, or build its recruiting product on the school-verified students it already has? my starting hunch ..... I came in with the calls from two earlier studies of mine. The LinkedIn Premium study picked Premium Career as the job seeker entry tier, and the Indeed study backed AI hiring software. how the hunch held up The first held in part. LinkedIn’s job match cut low-match applications by 10% for Premium users, so a paid signal does sort the pile. New grads complicate it, because Handshake is free to students and tied to their school, and LinkedIn’s own entry-level hiring fell 6%. The second got harder to hold. 70% of hiring managers say AI speeds up good decisions, yet 41% of job seekers admit to prompt injections and 25% of recruiters have no confidence in their AI systems. Screening software works better when the applicant behind the file is verified.
THE DATA, 4 TABLES
[01] nyfed_unemployment.csv ....................................................... 184 rows /studies/handshake-and-linkedin/data/nyfed_unemployment.csv Unemployment rates for recent graduates, all workers, all college graduates and young workers at quarter-end months from March 2015 to June 2026. where it came from The New York Fed’s Labor Market for Recent College Graduates data file, which it builds from the Current Population Survey. why i chose it ... It is the study’s one long time series, and it puts recent graduates beside the whole workforce on one definition. what it cannot tell us Anything about a platform. A recent graduate here is aged 22 to 27 with a bachelor’s degree or more, and small samples make that line jumpy from one reading to the next. The NY Fed also revises the series, and the table holds the values as pulled on October 31, 2026. [02] metrics.csv .................................................................. 135 rows /studies/handshake-and-linkedin/data/metrics.csv Every figure that appears once, covering new-grad hiring, application volume, trust in hiring and each platform’s business results. where it came from NACE, the NY Fed, BLS, Indeed Hiring Lab, LinkedIn, Handshake, Ashby, Greenhouse and press reports. why i chose it ... Each figure gets an ID, so the driver matrix and the code can point at the exact row. what it cannot tell us A like-for-like comparison across platforms. The rows come from separate surveys with separate bases, and 32 of the 135 come from a platform reporting on itself. Handshake is private, so its revenue rows are press reports and Sacra estimates. [03] events.csv ..................................................................... 8 rows /studies/handshake-and-linkedin/data/events.csv Dated Handshake moves from the launch of its AI line in January 2025 to September 2026. where it came from Handshake product updates and press coverage. why i chose it ... It puts dates on the turn toward AI training and on the change to open sign-up. what it cannot tell us Why Handshake made each move. 4 of the 8 rows are outside reports about a private company. [04] drivers.csv .................................................................... 8 rows /studies/handshake-and-linkedin/data/drivers.csv A matrix of 8 drivers of new-grad hiring, each scored 0 to 2 for Handshake and for its two rivals. where it came from My own coding, with the IDs of the rows each score rests on. why i chose it ... It shows where Handshake leads LinkedIn and where it trails, and each option answers one of those gaps. what it cannot tell us Stand as measurement. The scores are my judgment, and the row IDs are there so a reader can disagree. This table carries row IDs where the other three carry a URL.
THE PROCESS
[01] One row per figure
Each figure went into a row of its own with a source name, a URL, the date I retrieved
it and a flag for whether a platform reported it about itself. metrics.csv holds 135 of
them from 30 named sources.
[02] Quarter-end months
The NY Fed publishes its rates monthly. The table keeps the quarter-end months, which
gives 46 readings for each of the four series.
[03] Pivot
nyfed_unemployment.csv is long, with one row per series per month. I pivoted it to one
row per month and subtracted the all-worker rate from the recent-graduate rate.
[04] Ratios by row ID
Every ratio is computed from named rows. Growth in applications per hire divides row
AP06 by row AP04, and the AI share of Handshake’s revenue divides BZ05 by BZ06.
[05] Assumptions
Rounded statements enter as the number stated, and the notes column keeps the wording.
Row BZ05 reads “Reported as nearly $1B” and enters as 1,000 million dollars. Row BZ01
reads “Midpoint of reported $5M-$10M”. Where a source gave two values I kept one and
logged the other, as in row MK10, “Release body says 43%, page summary says 44%”.
[06] Check
The 36.5x offer multiple divides 7.3% by 0.2%, and the second number is printed to one
decimal. I rebuilt both offer rates from the stage rates, application to interview
times interview to offer. The stage rates are 2021 to 2024 averages and give 6.4% and
0.18%, a multiple of 35.6x. Rounding alone lets the reported multiple sit anywhere from
29.2x to 48.7x. All 24 row IDs cited in the driver matrix resolve to a row.
# One month before and after the pivot.
- Before, 4 rows of nyfed_unemployment.csv (5 of 10 columns shown)
- After, one row per month
Each value is a three-month average of a survey estimate. The gap is the recent-graduate
rate minus the all-worker rate, in percentage points.
# The code for the key steps
- The pivot from long rows to one row per month, with the gap.
derive.mjs ........ /studies/handshake-and-linkedin/derive.mjs
- The summary of that gap, before 2020 and since 2022.
derive.mjs ........ /studies/handshake-and-linkedin/derive.mjs
- The check on the offer multiple.
derive.mjs ........ /studies/handshake-and-linkedin/derive.mjs
# Dead ends
source of hire by platform
No national survey tracks where new graduates get hired by platform.
The closest I could get pairs Ashby’s conversion rates across all
roles with one college’s first-destination survey, and each has a
gap.
a current table of recruiting methods
The full table of methods employers use and rate comes from the NACE
2019 Internship & Co-op Survey, the latest edition with open
figures. Later NACE reports confirm the ranking in words only.THE 3 FINDINGS THAT CHANGE THE DECISION
[01] 1.6 points · Recent graduates 5.7% against all workers 4.1%, June 2026
Recent graduates have been out of work at a higher rate than all workers in all 18
quarter-end readings since 2022. From 2015 to 2019 they averaged 0.3 points below.
dataset .......... nyfed_unemployment.csv
query ............ derive.mjs, nyf()
# Recent graduates now sit 1.6 points above all workers
Unemployment rate at quarter-end months, as three-month averages. Recent graduates are
aged 22 to 27 with a bachelor’s degree or more, and all workers are aged 16 to 65.
quarter-end month
Unemployment rate (%)
all workers ...... Mar 2015 5.4, Jun 2015 5.3, Sep 2015 5.0, Dec 2015 5.0,
Mar 2016 4.8, Jun 2016 4.8, Sep 2016 4.7, Dec 2016 4.7,
Mar 2017 4.4, Jun 2017 4.2, Sep 2017 4.2, Dec 2017 4.0,
Mar 2018 3.9, Jun 2018 3.8, Sep 2018 3.6, Dec 2018 3.7,
Mar 2019 3.7, Jun 2019 3.5, Sep 2019 3.6, Dec 2019 3.5,
Mar 2020 3.7, Jun 2020 12.8, Sep 2020 8.4, Dec 2020 6.7,
Mar 2021 6.1, Jun 2021 6.0, Sep 2021 5.0, Dec 2021 4.2,
Mar 2022 3.8, Jun 2022 3.5, Sep 2022 3.4, Dec 2022 3.5,
Mar 2023 3.5, Jun 2023 3.5, Sep 2023 3.6, Dec 2023 3.7,
Mar 2024 3.7, Jun 2024 3.8, Sep 2024 4.0, Dec 2024 4.0,
Mar 2025 4.0, Jun 2025 4.0, Sep 2025 4.1, Dec 2025 4.3,
Mar 2026 4.2, Jun 2026 4.1
all college graduates
Mar 2015 2.8, Jun 2015 2.7, Sep 2015 2.6, Dec 2015 2.6,
Mar 2016 2.6, Jun 2016 2.6, Sep 2016 2.6, Dec 2016 2.6,
Mar 2017 2.5, Jun 2017 2.5, Sep 2017 2.4, Dec 2017 2.2,
Mar 2018 2.3, Jun 2018 2.2, Sep 2018 2.1, Dec 2018 2.3,
Mar 2019 2.2, Jun 2019 2.2, Sep 2019 2.3, Dec 2019 2.1,
Mar 2020 2.2, Jun 2020 8.1, Sep 2020 5.3, Dec 2020 4.3,
Mar 2021 3.9, Jun 2021 3.6, Sep 2021 2.9, Dec 2021 2.4,
Mar 2022 2.2, Jun 2022 2.1, Sep 2022 2.0, Dec 2022 2.1,
Mar 2023 2.1, Jun 2023 2.2, Sep 2023 2.3, Dec 2023 2.3,
Mar 2024 2.2, Jun 2024 2.4, Sep 2024 2.6, Dec 2024 2.6,
Mar 2025 2.6, Jun 2025 2.7, Sep 2025 2.9, Dec 2025 3.1,
Mar 2026 3.1, Jun 2026 2.9
recent graduates
Mar 2015 5.1, Jun 2015 4.4, Sep 2015 4.6, Dec 2015 4.4,
Mar 2016 3.7, Jun 2016 4.0, Sep 2016 4.1, Dec 2016 3.8,
Mar 2017 4.2, Jun 2017 4.1, Sep 2017 3.8, Dec 2017 3.5,
Mar 2018 3.8, Jun 2018 3.6, Sep 2018 3.6, Dec 2018 4.1,
Mar 2019 3.6, Jun 2019 4.3, Sep 2019 4.0, Dec 2019 3.6,
Mar 2020 3.9, Jun 2020 13.4, Sep 2020 9.0, Dec 2020 6.7,
Mar 2021 6.5, Jun 2021 6.2, Sep 2021 5.2, Dec 2021 4.7,
Mar 2022 3.9, Jun 2022 4.2, Sep 2022 4.0, Dec 2022 4.1,
Mar 2023 4.0, Jun 2023 4.3, Sep 2023 4.4, Dec 2023 4.9,
Mar 2024 4.5, Jun 2024 4.7, Sep 2024 5.3, Dec 2024 4.8,
Mar 2025 5.7, Jun 2025 4.9, Sep 2025 5.8, Dec 2025 5.6,
Mar 2026 5.6, Jun 2026 5.7
source ........... nyfed_unemployment.csv, derive.mjs, nyfWide(), derive.mjs, nyf()
[02] 43.4% · Employers who have caught AI-written applications, against 20.1% with a tool to
screen for AI help
43.4% of employers have detected AI-written applications and 20.1% use a tool to detect
AI help, while applications per hire have risen 140% since early 2021.
dataset .......... metrics.csv
query ............ derive.mjs, ratios()
# 43.4% of employers have detected AI-written applications and 20.1% have a detection
tool
Share of employers in NACE’s spring survey, with 159 respondents to each question. The
detection-tool question covers the whole hiring process, so it is wider than
applications alone.
Employers that ................................................. Share of employers (%)
Have detected AI-written applications ........................................... 43.4%
Survey: NACE Job Outlook 2026 Spring Update · Fielded: 2026-02/2026-03 · Row: AP13
Are unsure whether they received any ............................................ 35.2%
Survey: NACE Job Outlook 2026 Spring Update · Fielded: 2026-02/2026-03 · Row: AP15
Use a tool to detect AI help .................................................... 20.1%
Survey: NACE Job Outlook 2026 Spring Update · Fielded: 2026-02/2026-03 · Row: AP14
source ........... metrics.csv, derive.mjs, ratios()
[03] 36.5x · Offer rate per application, 7.3% referred against 0.2% for people who applied
on their own
Referrals are about 1% of applications and about 18% of hires, and a referred applicant
gets an offer 36.5x as often as someone who applied on their own.
dataset .......... metrics.csv
query ............ derive.mjs, ratios()
# Referred applicants get an offer 36.5x as often as those who apply on their own
Offers per 100 applications across Ashby customers, all roles, Q4 2024. The stage rates
in the detail are 2021 to 2024 averages. The rate for people who applied on their own
is printed to one decimal, so the multiple could sit between 29.2x and 48.7x. Rebuilt
from the stage rates it is 35.6x.
Applicant source ....................................... Offer rate per application (%)
Referred applicants .............................................................. 7.3%
Application to interview: 40% · Interview to offer: 16%
Inbound applicants ............................................................... 0.2%
Application to interview: 3% · Interview to offer: 6%
source ........... metrics.csv, derive.mjs, ratios(), derive.mjs, offerCheck()MY RECOMMENDATION
Sell employers verified applicants first, then build referrals and proof of skill on top.
[A] Sell a verified applicant channel
Require a school link before any job application, which reverses the 2026 sign-up
change for that one step. Cap applications per student each week, and charge employers
for a premium tier built on those applicants.
evidence ......... Finding 2. 43.4% of employers have detected AI-written applications
and 20.1% have a tool for it, and Handshake drew 26% more
applications per job in a year. On my 0-to-2 scale, Handshake scores
2 on verified identity and 0 on limits to application volume.
main risk ........ It reverses part of the 2026 sign-up change, and the case rests on
one NACE survey with 159 respondents. Nothing in the data tests
whether employers would pay for verified applicants.
[B] Build referrals into the student graph
Match students with alumni at hiring companies and let those alumni refer them inside
Handshake.
evidence ......... Finding 3. Referred applicants get offers 36.5x as often as people
who applied on their own, and 44% of Gen Z name a missing network as
their biggest barrier. On my 0-to-2 scale for referral networks,
Handshake scores 0 and LinkedIn scores 2.
main risk ........ The Ashby rates cover experienced hires too. Referral rates for new
grads are likely lower, since few have a network yet.
[C] Turn Handshake AI work into proof of skill
Let students publish verified work from Handshake AI projects and AI Skills Studio
missions to employer profiles.
evidence ......... Postings that mention AI nearly doubled to 4.2% of full-time roles,
and Class of 2026 resumes mention AI skills more than 9x as often as
Class of 2022 resumes. It ties the business behind 87% of gross
revenue back to recruiting.
main risk ........ Both figures in the case are Handshake’s own, and nothing in the
data shows an employer hiring on AI project work.
- School-verified students go first because they’re the one thing LinkedIn and Indeed
would find hardest to copy.
- Employers need this now. 43.4% have caught AI-written applications, and only 20.1% have
a tool to screen for them.
- Referrals and proof of skill both build on those verified applicants.LIMITS AND NEXT STEPS
# What the data cannot support
- No dataset tracks source of hire for new grads nationally. The referral rates cover all
roles, and the one direct reading is a single college where Handshake accounted for 10%
of post-grad jobs.
- Handshake publishes no financials. Its revenue rows are press reports and Sacra
estimates, and the gross figures include contractor pay.
- 32 of the 135 figures in metrics.csv come from a platform reporting on itself.
- The sources define a new grad differently. The NY Fed counts bachelor’s graduates aged
22 to 27. Handshake counts early-talent roles, and Indeed’s entry-level class includes
hourly work.
- The driver scores are my judgment on a 0 to 2 scale.
- The NY Fed revises its series. The table holds my October 31, 2026 pull, and the live
file has since moved by enough to change the first decimal of the latest recent-graduate
rate.
# What I would test with more access
- With Handshake’s own data I would compare offer rates for school-verified applicants
against applicants who signed up with any email.
- I would pull Google Trends search interest for each platform.
- I would build an independent recent-graduate series from the BLS Current Population
Survey microdata.TL;DR
studied ............... How Handshake can win new-grad hiring against LinkedIn and Indeed. found ................. In June 2026, 5.7% of recent graduates were out of work, against 4.1% of all workers. # by the numbers 1.6 points .......... Recent graduates over all workers 291 ................. Applications per hire on Ashby 36.5x ............... Offer rate, referred against applied on their own the catch ............. No dataset tracks source of hire for new grads nationally. The referral rates cover all roles. next .................. With Handshake’s own data, compare offer rates for school-verified applicants against sign-ups with any email.
# end of /machine/handshake-and-linkedin. andrew.leng.ly@gmail.com · leave machine mode