Skip to content

analyst.andrewlengly.com/studies/third-places :: the case for third places

# Seven studies on loneliness and the places people gather, built to decide where FourthSpace launches in Sacramento. Americans 15 and up spend 26.5 minutes a day with friends, down from 60.0 in 2003. A data study by Andrew Leng Ly.

designed page ......... analyst.andrewlengly.com/studies/third-places

THE CASE FOR THIRD PLACES

analyst work .......... /machine/analyst
data study ............ November 2026

question .............. Is there a real case for third places in Sacramento, and where
                        should FourthSpace launch first?
headline finding ...... Time with friends fell from 60.0 to 26.5 minutes a day between 2003
                        and 2025. Sacramento County is lonelier than 95% of U.S. counties,
                        and 36 of its neighborhoods (census tracts) pair high loneliness
                        with low walk access to any indoor place to gather.
my recommendation ..... Launch in south Sacramento, with the library branches near the
                        loneliness hot spots as the first anchor venues.
tools ................. Python 3.13 and pandas · statsmodels and SciPy for the models ·
                        Survey weights with Taylor-linearized variance · geopandas and
                        networkx for the walk network · esda for the hot spots · matplotlib
                        and Plotly for the first charts · JavaScript on Node for the numbers
                        on this page · React and SVG for the charts on this page

THE QUESTION

the client ............ FourthSpace, the community app I’m building for finding third places
                        that are open right now. It launches in Sacramento, and the findings
                        also go into its pitch deck and landing page.
the decision they face
                        Where FourthSpace starts in Sacramento and who it starts with. I
                        weighed five launch options against the findings.
my starting hunch ..... I came in thinking tech use, phones and social media most of all,
                        drives people into isolation and loneliness.
how the hunch held up
                        I was partly right. Time with friends fell by more than half, and
                        heavy social media users reported worse mental health in 485 of 540
                        models. Bullying and weak ties at school went with far larger gaps
                        in teen sadness. None of it shows cause.

THE DATA, 10 TABLES

[01] atus_with_whom_by_year_age.csv ............................................... 161 rows
     /studies/third-places/data/atus_with_whom_by_year_age.csv
     Weighted minutes a day alone and with friends or family, by age group, for every
     American Time Use Survey year from 2003 to 2025.
     where it came from
                        BLS American Time Use Survey microdata, weighted with the survey’s
                        final weights.
     why i chose it ... Finding 1. The diary records who a person was with through the day,
                        so friends time is measured directly.
     what it cannot tell us
                        It covers one diary day per person. The 2025 sample has 6,146
                        diaries against 20,720 in 2003, so recent years carry wider error.

[02] benchmarks.csv ................................................................ 52 rows
     /studies/third-places/data/benchmarks.csv
     Adjusted gaps in persistent sadness and poor mental health that go with social media
     use, bullying, sleep, sports and ties at school, in 2023 and 2025.
     where it came from
                        CDC Youth Risk Behavior Survey microdata, read from the fixed-width
                        files and weighted with its strata and clusters.
     why i chose it ... Finding 2. It puts social media on the same scale as the rest of a
                        teen’s life.
     what it cannot tell us
                        Cause. Each wave surveys different students once.

[03] spec_curve_results.csv ....................................................... 540 rows
     /studies/third-places/data/spec_curve_results.csv
     All 540 models of the social media link: six definitions of heavy use crossed with
     outcomes, control sets, samples and survey years.
     where it came from
                        My own runs on the YRBS 2023 and 2025 files, each a survey-weighted
                        linear probability model.
     why i chose it ... The other side of the debate. One model can be tuned toward an
                        answer, so I ran every reasonable one and report the spread.
     what it cannot tell us
                        Settle direction. Sad teens may turn to social media as much as
                        social media makes teens sad.

[04] places_sacramento_county.csv ................................................... 4 rows
     /studies/third-places/data/places_sacramento_county.csv
     Sacramento County’s loneliness rate and two related measures, with the U.S. and
     California county medians and its rank.
     where it came from
                        CDC PLACES, 2023 data in the 2025 release, which models BRFSS
                        answers down to each county.
     why i chose it ... Finding 3, and the adult count behind my Sacramento estimate.
     what it cannot tell us
                        Stand as a direct count. PLACES rates come from a model, and the
                        477,000 figure is my estimate built on one.

[05] cbp_third_places_1998_2023.csv ............................................... 520 rows
     /studies/third-places/data/cbp_third_places_1998_2023.csv
     Establishments in 9 kinds of gathering place for the U.S. and Sacramento County, every
     year from 1998 to 2023, with a rate per 10,000 residents.
     where it came from
                        Census County Business Patterns county files, with industry codes
                        mapped across the 2002, 2007, 2012 and 2017 revisions.
     why i chose it ... Finding 4. It shows which kinds of place grew and which shrank.
                        Sacramento County went from 206 coffee shops and snack bars to 501.
     what it cannot tell us
                        Visits. A count of businesses says nothing about how many people go
                        or how long they stay.

[06] atus_minutes_by_place.csv ..................................................... 23 rows
     /studies/third-places/data/atus_minutes_by_place.csv
     Weighted waking minutes a day by location, from home to restaurants and places of
     worship.
     where it came from
                        BLS American Time Use Survey activity file and its location codes.
     why i chose it ... The time behind finding 4. Fewer gathering places matter more if
                        people also spend less time out.
     what it cannot tell us
                        Who was there. A minute at a restaurant can be spent alone.

[07] imls_sacramento_public_library.csv ............................................ 27 rows
     /studies/third-places/data/imls_sacramento_public_library.csv
     Sacramento Public Library visits and service population by fiscal year.
     where it came from
                        IMLS Public Libraries Survey.
     why i chose it ... Option B. The branches have space to fill and a visit gap to close.
     what it cannot tell us
                        Branch detail. The survey counts visits for the whole system.

[08] atus_workday_company_by_type.csv ............................................... 4 rows
     /studies/third-places/data/atus_workday_company_by_type.csv
     Minutes alone, with coworkers, with friends and with anyone outside the household on
     days with 4 or more hours of work, split by where the work happened.
     where it came from
                        BLS American Time Use Survey activity, location and who files, 2010
                        to 2019 and 2021 to 2025.
     why i chose it ... Finding 5.
     what it cannot tell us
                        Choice. People who work from home may differ from office workers in
                        ways a diary can’t see.

[09] acs1_wfh_share.csv ............................................................ 30 rows
     /studies/third-places/data/acs1_wfh_share.csv
     Workers who usually work from home, for five areas from the whole U.S. down to the city
     of Sacramento.
     where it came from
                        Census ACS 1-year table B08301, read from the summary files.
     why i chose it ... It sizes the remote worker group in Sacramento County.
     what it cannot tell us
                        Hybrid days. The ACS asks how people usually get to work, so someone
                        home two days a week counts as a commuter.

[10] priority_tracts.csv ........................................................... 36 rows
     /studies/third-places/data/priority_tracts.csv
     The 36 Sacramento County census tracts that pair higher loneliness with low walk access
     to an indoor gathering place.
     where it came from
                        CDC PLACES tract estimates and OpenStreetMap venues pulled in
                        November 2026, measured on a walk network built from Census TIGER
                        2024 roads.
     why i chose it ... Finding 6, and option A.
     what it cannot tell us
                        Every venue. OpenStreetMap misses places, and walk access counts
                        street intersections near a venue as a stand-in for homes.

THE PROCESS

[01] Questions first
     I scoped ten questions and ran seven. Each one ties to a choice FourthSpace has to make
     about its message or its launch.

[02] Microdata
     I read the raw files for the ATUS diaries and the two CDC surveys, BRFSS and YRBS. Each
     estimate uses the survey’s own design weights and clusters. My helper computes
     Taylor-linearized variance, the same method R’s survey package uses for a linear model.

[03] Check against the source
     Before writing any finding, I checked my weighted rates against the figures the CDC and
     Census publish for the same year.

[04] Every model
     For the social media question I ran all 540 combinations of five analyst choices and
     kept the full spread, so no single model carries the result.

[05] On foot
     For Sacramento I built a walk network from TIGER roads with freeways and ramps removed.
     Each tract’s access is the share of its street intersections within 800 meters of an
     indoor gathering place. Local Moran’s I found the loneliness hot spots.

[06] One stat bank
     Every figure went into a stat bank with its year, geography, source, link and caveat,
     plus a flag for whether it is safe for the landing page. This page reads 1,397 rows
     from 10 of the clean tables behind it.

[07] Into the product
     The findings became a 12-slide pitch deck for FourthSpace and a ranked list of venues
     to call.

  # U.S. bookstores in County Business Patterns, before and after the code fix.
  - First run, the 2022 and 2023 files read with the new industry code
  - After, three rows of cbp_third_places_1998_2023.csv (three of eight columns shown)
  The 2022 and 2023 files still file bookstores under the 2017 industry code. Reading them
  with the 2022 code matched nothing, so bookstores dropped to zero. I kept the 2017 code
  for every year.

  # The code for the key steps
  - The weighting helper every survey estimate ran through.
    survey.py ......... /studies/third-places/scripts/survey.py
  - The spread of all the social media models behind the verdict.
    derive.mjs ........ /studies/third-places/derive.mjs
  - The count of lonely adults in the priority tracts, behind finding 6.
    derive.mjs ........ /studies/third-places/derive.mjs

  # Dead ends
  the census api wanted a key
                        The ACS calls in my fetch script came back as a page asking for an
                        API key. I switched to the summary files on the Census file server,
                        which need none.
  library visits before 1998
                        The IMLS files from the 1990s name the visits field ATTEND, and
                        those years didn’t line up with the rest. The library series starts
                        in fiscal 1998.
  an institution at the top
                        A special land-use tract, likely an institution, topped my first
                        priority ranking. Tracts numbered 98xx and 99xx are now out of every
                        ranking.
  curvy roads counted twice
                        My first access measure counted every point along a road’s shape,
                        which favored winding streets. It now counts intersections only.
  a wrong place name
                        My first map caption put the hot spots in the northern suburbs.
                        Matched to ZIP codes, they sit in south and north Sacramento, so I
                        rewrote it.
  a title the data didn’t back
                        One chart title said teens who skip social media are not the
                        happiest. That held in 2023 and failed in 2025. The title now
                        describes both years.

THE 6 FINDINGS THAT CHANGE THE DECISION

[01] 26.5 min · a day with friends, ages 15 and up, 2025
     Americans 15 and up spent 26.5 minutes a day with friends in 2025, down from 60.0 in
     2003. They spent 49 more minutes a day alone.
     dataset .......... atus_with_whom_by_year_age.csv
     query ............ derive.mjs, friendsChange()

     # Time with friends fell to 26.5 minutes a day
     Averages from American Time Use Survey diaries, weighted to the population. Ages 15 to
     24 fell the most, from 155.1 to 53.6 minutes.
     year ............. Minutes a day with friends
     ages 15 to 24 .... 2003 155.1, 2004 145.1, 2005 150.2, 2006 123.0, 2007 113.2,
                        2008 116.1, 2009 111.3, 2010 133.5, 2011 126.3, 2012 125.1,
                        2013 123.2, 2014 104.5, 2015 104.7, 2016 99.1, 2017 90.3, 2018 91.2,
                        2019 68.6, 2020 43.8, 2021 49.4, 2022 51.0, 2023 55.8, 2024 46.4,
                        2025 53.6
     everyone 15 and up
                        2003 60.0, 2004 60.0, 2005 56.4, 2006 51.5, 2007 51.8, 2008 50.2,
                        2009 51.1, 2010 56.4, 2011 54.7, 2012 54.7, 2013 54.8, 2014 50.2,
                        2015 48.8, 2016 47.2, 2017 41.5, 2018 40.7, 2019 34.3, 2020 19.7,
                        2021 23.3, 2022 24.1, 2023 25.9, 2024 25.7, 2025 26.5
     source ........... atus_with_whom_by_year_age.csv, derive.mjs, friendsByYear()

[02] +17.3 · points of persistent sadness for students not close to people at school,
     against +8.3 for heavy social media use
     In 2025, students who don’t feel close to people at school reported persistent sadness
     17.3 points more often than other students. Using social media more than once an hour
     went with 8.3 points.
     dataset .......... benchmarks.csv
     query ............ derive.mjs, teenGaps()

     # School life tracks teen sadness more closely than heavy social media use
     U.S. high school students, 2025. Each bar comes from its own model, weighted to the
     population and adjusted for demographics. Across all 540 social media models the median
     gap is 5.0 points, 7.6 for girls and 3.0 for boys. These are associations from one
     survey wave.
     Factor ............................................. Extra points of persistent sadness
     Bullied electronically ........................................................... 31.3
       95% interval: 27.9 to 34.6 · Share of students: 14.6% · Students in the model: 9,562
     Bullied at school ................................................................ 27.8
       95% interval: 24.1 to 31.6 · Share of students: 19.7% · Students in the model: 9,570
     Does not feel close to people at school .......................................... 17.3
       95% interval: 14.2 to 20.4 · Share of students: 36.8% · Students in the model: 8,468
     Sleeps under 8 hours on school nights ............................................ 14.1
       95% interval: 10.9 to 17.2 · Share of students: 75.7% · Students in the model: 7,888
     Plays on no sports team .......................................................... 10.7
       95% interval: 6.9 to 14.5 · Share of students: 42.4% · Students in the model: 6,392
     Uses social media more than once an hour .......................................... 8.3
       95% interval: 5.6 to 10.9 · Share of students: 28.4% · Students in the model: 8,886
     source ........... benchmarks.csv, derive.mjs, teenGaps(), spec_curve_results.csv,
                        derive.mjs, specCurve()

[03] ≈477,000 · adults in Sacramento County who feel lonely at least sometimes, my estimate
     Sacramento County’s loneliness rate, adjusted for age, was 39.5% in 2023, higher than
     95% of the 2,300 U.S. counties with an estimate and second of 58 in California.
     dataset .......... places_sacramento_county.csv
     query ............ derive.mjs, sacramento()

     # Sacramento County is lonelier than 95% of U.S. counties
     CDC PLACES model-based estimates for 2023. My count of about 477,000 adults multiplies
     the unadjusted rate of 38.9% by 1,226,535 adults, with a range of 426,000 to 532,000.
     Place ..................... Adults who feel lonely at least sometimes, age-adjusted (%)
     Sacramento County ............................................................... 39.5%
       95% interval: 35.3 to 44.2 · Rank in California: 2 of 58
     California county median ........................................................ 36.2%
       Counties: 58
     U.S. county median .............................................................. 34.0%
       Counties: 2,300
     source ........... places_sacramento_county.csv, derive.mjs, sacramento()

[04] +91% · coffee shops and snack bars per resident, 1998 to 2023
     Coffee shops per resident grew 91% from 1998 to 2023 and civic and social organizations
     fell 40%. Americans now spend 74 more waking minutes a day at home than in 2003.
     dataset .......... cbp_third_places_1998_2023.csv
     query ............ derive.mjs, supplyIndex()

     # Coffee shops per person nearly doubled, and civic clubs fell 40%
     Establishments per 10,000 U.S. residents, 2023 against 1998. A bar at 100 means no
     change, and all establishments together sit at 99. Time at third places fell from 83 to
     67 minutes a day between 2003 and 2025.
     Kind of place .................................... 2023 level per resident (1998 = 100)
     Coffee shops and snack bars ....................................................... 191
       Per 10,000 in 1998: 1.31 · Per 10,000 in 2023: 2.50 · Establishments in 2023: 84,105
     Fitness and recreation centers .................................................... 151
       Per 10,000 in 1998: 0.79 · Per 10,000 in 2023: 1.20 · Establishments in 2023: 40,307
     Barber shops ...................................................................... 143
       Per 10,000 in 1998: 0.15 · Per 10,000 in 2023: 0.21 · Establishments in 2023: 7,231
     Full-service restaurants .......................................................... 110
       Per 10,000 in 1998: 6.99 · Per 10,000 in 2023: 7.66 · Establishments in 2023: 258,273
     Religious organizations ............................................................ 95
       Per 10,000 in 1998: 5.84 · Per 10,000 in 2023: 5.54 · Establishments in 2023: 186,615
     Bars and taverns ................................................................... 62
       Per 10,000 in 1998: 1.91 · Per 10,000 in 2023: 1.18 · Establishments in 2023: 39,855
     Civic and social organizations ..................................................... 60
       Per 10,000 in 1998: 1.16 · Per 10,000 in 2023: 0.70 · Establishments in 2023: 23,488
     Bookstores ......................................................................... 31
       Per 10,000 in 1998: 0.44 · Per 10,000 in 2023: 0.14 · Establishments in 2023: 4,647
     Bowling centers .................................................................... 28
       Per 10,000 in 1998: 0.20 · Per 10,000 in 2023: 0.05 · Establishments in 2023: 1,820
     source ........... cbp_third_places_1998_2023.csv, derive.mjs, supplyIndex(),
                        atus_minutes_by_place.csv, derive.mjs, placeMinutes()

[05] 57 min · with anyone outside the household on a home workday, 2021 to 2025
     On days worked from home in 2021 to 2025, people spent 57 minutes with anyone outside
     their household, against 423 on days at the workplace.
     dataset .......... atus_workday_company_by_type.csv
     query ............ derive.mjs, workdayCompany()

     # Home workdays hold 57 minutes with anyone outside the household
     U.S. employed people on days with 4 or more hours of work. 2020 is left out. Most of
     the gap is coworkers, and time with friends is about the same on both kinds of day.
     Workday ..................................... Minutes with anyone outside the household
     At home, 2021 to 2025 .............................................................. 57
       With coworkers: 14 min · With friends: 12 min · Alone: 10.7 hours · Diary days: 2,505
     At the workplace, 2021 to 2025 .................................................... 423
       With coworkers: 374 min · With friends: 11 min · Alone: 5.8 hours · Diary days: 6,912
     At home, 2010 to 2019 ............................................................. 118
       With coworkers: 34 min · With friends: 25 min · Alone: 9.3 hours · Diary days: 2,408
     At the workplace, 2010 to 2019 .................................................... 486
       With coworkers: 423 min · With friends: 26 min · Alone: 4.9 hours · Diary days:
       25,761
     source ........... atus_workday_company_by_type.csv, derive.mjs, workdayCompany()

[06] ≈52,000 · lonely adults in 36 neighborhoods with little nearby to gather, my estimate
     36 Sacramento County neighborhoods (census tracts) pair higher loneliness with low walk
     access to an indoor gathering place. They hold about 52,000 lonely adults, and 34 of
     them have no indoor venue mapped at all.
     dataset .......... priority_tracts.csv
     query ............ derive.mjs, priorityTotals()

     # 36 neighborhoods hold about 52,000 lonely adults with little nearby to gather
     The 8 of the 36 that hold the most. Walk access is the share of a neighborhood’s street
     intersections within 800 meters of an indoor gathering place, about a 10-minute walk.
     Census tract .................................................. Estimated lonely adults
     Tract 70.11 ..................................................................... 2,146
       Lonely at least sometimes: 42.5% · Walk access: 9% · Indoor venues mapped: 0
     Tract 96.10 ..................................................................... 2,135
       Lonely at least sometimes: 42.8% · Walk access: 0% · Indoor venues mapped: 0
     Tract 93.11 ..................................................................... 2,070
       Lonely at least sometimes: 40.8% · Walk access: 0% · Indoor venues mapped: 0
     Tract 48.01 ..................................................................... 2,018
       Lonely at least sometimes: 44.6% · Walk access: 9% · Indoor venues mapped: 3
     Tract 93.21 ..................................................................... 1,886
       Lonely at least sometimes: 42.4% · Walk access: 0% · Indoor venues mapped: 0
     Tract 93.34 ..................................................................... 1,855
       Lonely at least sometimes: 41.3% · Walk access: 6% · Indoor venues mapped: 0
     Tract 93.19 ..................................................................... 1,813
       Lonely at least sometimes: 42.9% · Walk access: 2% · Indoor venues mapped: 0
     Tract 64 ........................................................................ 1,809
       Lonely at least sometimes: 42.2% · Walk access: 0% · Indoor venues mapped: 0
     source ........... priority_tracts.csv, derive.mjs, priorityTop(),
                        derive.mjs, priorityTotals()

MY RECOMMENDATION

  Launch in south Sacramento’s loneliest neighborhoods, with library branches as the first
  venues.

[A] Launch in the loneliest neighborhoods
     Start the pilot in south Sacramento along the Florin Rd and Stockton Blvd corridors,
     where most of the hot spot tracts sit.
     evidence ......... Findings 3 and 6. 22 of the 36 priority neighborhoods sit inside a
                        loneliness hot spot, and the 36 together hold about 52,000 lonely
                        adults.
     main risk ........ 34 of those neighborhoods have no indoor venue mapped, so early
                        users may open the app and find few places nearby.

[B] Make the library system the anchor partner
     Pitch Sacramento Public Library branches near the hot spots as the first venues,
     starting with Southgate and Valley Hi-North Laguna.
     evidence ......... Sacramento Public Library logged 2,010,888 visits in fiscal 2024,
                        54% of its fiscal 2019 count. Branches are free to use and run their
                        own events.
     main risk ........ Public agencies take time to approve partners, which could push back
                        the launch.

  - Start where the need is. Most of the priority neighborhoods sit inside a loneliness hot
    spot.
  - The libraries cover the biggest risk. Almost none of those neighborhoods has an indoor
    venue mapped, and the Southgate and Valley Hi-North Laguna branches are free to use and
    already run events.
  - If library approval runs long, the branches can still be listed as public places while
    the partnership is worked out.

LIMITS AND NEXT STEPS

  # What the data cannot support
  - Show cause. Every link between loneliness, phones, places and health on this page is an
    association.
  - The Sacramento rates are model-based. PLACES fills in counties and tracts from a
    statewide model, so the 477,000 and 52,000 figures are estimates built on estimates.
  - Business counts and diary minutes say nothing about how a place feels or whether people
    meet anyone there.
  - Walk access depends on OpenStreetMap. A venue missing from the map makes a tract look
    emptier than it is.

  # What I would test with more access
  - Ask the California Healthy Kids Survey for Sacramento County results to see whether the
    school ties pattern holds for local teens.
  - Add two optional questions to the FourthSpace waitlist on loneliness and volunteering,
    to build a first-party measure over time.
  - Test foot traffic data from Advan or SafeGraph in the priority tracts. It costs money,
    so it stays optional.
  - Rerun finding 5 with the 2026 ACS once it shows what the return-to-office order did.

TL;DR

studied ............... Where my community app FourthSpace should launch in Sacramento,
                        worked out across seven studies on loneliness.
found ................. Americans 15 and up went from 60.0 minutes a day with friends in
                        2003 to 26.5 in 2025.
  # by the numbers
  26.5 min ............ A day with friends, 2025
  ≈477,000 ............ Lonely adults in Sacramento County, my estimate
  ≈52,000 ............. Lonely adults in 36 neighborhoods with little nearby
the catch ............. The Sacramento rates come from a statewide model, so 477,000 and
                        52,000 are estimates built on estimates.
next .................. Ask the California Healthy Kids Survey for Sacramento County results
                        to test the school ties pattern locally.

# end of /machine/third-places. andrew.leng.ly@gmail.com · leave machine mode