Skip to content

andrewlengly.com/third-places-casestudy :: the case for third places case study

# Seven studies on loneliness and the places people gather, run to decide where FourthSpace, the community app I’m building, launches in Sacramento.

designed page ......... /third-places-casestudy

THE SHORT VERSION

  A series of seven data studies on loneliness and the places people gather, run to decide
  where FourthSpace launches in Sacramento. It runs survey-weighted models on federal
  microdata, including 540 versions of the social media link, and maps walk access to indoor
  venues across Sacramento County. Built with Python, pandas, statsmodels and geopandas, it
  recommends a launch in south Sacramento with library branches as the first venues.

the question .......... Do people need more places to meet in person, and where in
                        Sacramento should FourthSpace start?
what i did ............ Ran seven studies on time diaries, CDC surveys, county business
                        counts and a walk network I built for Sacramento. Every figure went
                        into one stat bank with its source.
where it stands ....... Done in November 2026. I picked south Sacramento for the launch,
                        with library branches as the first venues. The findings also went
                        into the FourthSpace pitch deck.

kind .................. Case study · Data study
role .................. Analyst
year .................. 2026
tools ................. Python, pandas, statsmodels, SciPy, geopandas, networkx, esda,
                        Plotly

the question .......... Do people need more places to meet in person, and where in
                        Sacramento should FourthSpace start?

THE QUESTION

  # An app for meeting people in person only works if people want to meet.

  FourthSpace is a community app I’m building for finding third places that are open right
  now. Think coffee shops, libraries, trails and farmers markets. It launches in Sacramento.

  Before launch I wanted the data to settle where in Sacramento it starts and who it starts
  with.

  I came in thinking phones and social media push people into isolation. I was partly right.

HOW I DID IT

  # Seven studies on public microdata, with every number kept in one stat bank.

  # From ten questions to a launch pick
  01. Scope
      10 questions scoped
      7 run, each tied to a launch call
  02. Microdata
      ATUS diaries, 2003 to 2025
      CDC YRBS and PLACES
  03. Weights
      Each survey’s design weights
      Taylor-linearized variance
  04. Every model
      540 social media models
      The full spread kept
      Why: One model can be tuned toward an answer, so I ran every reasonable one
  05. On foot
      Walk network from TIGER roads
      Freeways and ramps removed
  06. Stat bank
      Year, source and caveat per figure
      A flag for landing page use

walk access ........... the share of a tract’s street intersections within 800 meters of an
                        indoor gathering place, about a 10-minute walk
priority tract ........ a census tract with higher loneliness and low walk access
lonely adults ......... the CDC PLACES crude rate times the adults who live there, an
                        estimate built on a model
  Before writing any finding, I checked my weighted rates against the figures the CDC and
  Census publish for the same year.

  # What I fixed along the way
bookstores at zero .... The 2022 and 2023 business files still list bookstores under the
                        2017 industry code. Reading them with the new code matched nothing,
                        so I kept the 2017 code for every year.
winding roads counted twice
                        My first access measure counted every point along a road’s shape. It
                        now counts intersections only.
an institution on top
                        A special land-use tract topped my first ranking. Tracts numbered
                        98xx and 99xx are now out of every ranking.
a wrong place name .... My first map caption put the hot spots in the northern suburbs.
                        Matched to ZIP codes, they sit in south and north Sacramento.

WHAT THE DATA SHOWS

  # Time with friends fell by more than half since 2003.

  # Minutes a day with friends, Americans 15 and up
2003 .................. 60.0
2008 .................. 50.2
2013 .................. 54.8
2019 .................. 34.3
2020 .................. 19.7
2025 .................. 26.5
  Weighted American Time Use Survey diary means. Ages 15 to 24 fell from 155 to 54 minutes,
  and everyone spent 49 more minutes a day alone. 2020 was the pandemic low.

  # Extra points of persistent sadness, U.S. high school students, 2025
bullied electronically
                        +31.3
bullied at school ..... +27.8
does not feel close to people at school
                        +17.3
sleeps under 8 hours on school nights
                        +14.1
plays on no sports team
                        +10.7
uses social media more than once an hour
                        +8.3
  Each bar is its own survey-weighted model with demographic controls. Across all 540 social
  media models, 485 put heavy users at higher risk, with a median gap of 5.0 points.

  Heavy social media use does go with more sadness. Bullying and weak ties at school go with
  far larger gaps. Each bar is an association from one survey wave, and the direction is
  open too, since sad teens may turn to social media more.

SACRAMENTO

  # Sacramento County is lonelier than 95% of U.S. counties.

adults lonely at least sometimes, 2023
                        39.5%
california counties, loneliest first
                        2 of 58
lonely adults in the county, my estimate
                        ≈477K
priority tracts ....... 36

  # Adults who feel lonely at least sometimes, age-adjusted, 2023
sacramento county ..... 39.5%
california county median
                        36.2%
u.s. county median .... 34.0%
  CDC PLACES model-based estimates.

  The 36 priority tracts hold about 52,000 lonely adults, and 22 of them sit inside a
  loneliness hot spot. Of those tracts, 34 have no indoor venue mapped at all.

  Most of the hot spot tracts sit along the Florin Rd and Stockton Blvd corridors in south
  Sacramento.

WHERE PEOPLE GATHER

  # Civic clubs per person fell by 40% in 25 years.

  # U.S. establishments per resident in 2023, 1998 = 100
coffee shops and snack bars
                        191
fitness and recreation centers
                        151
barber shops .......... 143
full-service restaurants
                        110
all establishments .... 99
religious organizations
                        95
bars and taverns ...... 62
civic and social organizations
                        60
bookstores ............ 31
bowling centers ....... 28
  Census County Business Patterns. In Sacramento County, civic and social organizations per
  resident fell 34%, and 92 remain with paid staff.

  # Minutes with anyone outside the household on a workday, 2021 to 2025
working from home ..... 57
at the workplace ...... 423
  U.S. employed people on days with 4 or more hours of work. Most of the gap is coworkers.
  Time with friends is about the same on both kinds of day.

  Americans spent 83 minutes a day at third places in 2003 and 67 in 2025. Time at home grew
  by 74 minutes a day over the same years.

MY RECOMMENDATION

  # Launch in south Sacramento, with the library branches as the first venues.

  A. Start in the loneliest neighborhoods
    why ............... 22 of the 36 priority tracts sit inside a loneliness hot spot, along
                        Florin Rd and Stockton Blvd
    risk .............. 34 of those tracts have no indoor venue mapped, so early users may
                        find few places nearby

  B. Make the library the anchor partner
    why ............... Sacramento Public Library logged 2,010,888 visits in fiscal 2024,
                        54% of its fiscal 2019 count, and its branches are free and run
                        their own events
    risk .............. Public agencies take time to approve partners
    together .......... The Southgate and Valley Hi-North Laguna branches give early users
                        in those tracts somewhere to go

  If library approval runs long, the branches can still be listed as public places while the
  partnership is worked out. The research also became a 12-slide pitch deck and a ranked
  list of venues to call.

LIMITS

  # What this data can’t tell you.

cause ................. Every link between loneliness, phones, places and health in these
                        studies is an association.
modeled rates ......... PLACES fills in counties and tracts from a statewide model, so the
                        477,000 and 52,000 figures are estimates built on estimates.
counts and minutes .... Business counts and diary minutes say nothing about how a place
                        feels or whether people meet anyone there.
map gaps .............. Walk access depends on OpenStreetMap. A venue missing from the map
                        makes a tract look emptier than it is.

WHAT’S NEXT

  # What I’d add with local and first-party data.

local teens ........... Ask the California Healthy Kids Survey for Sacramento County
                        results, to see whether the school ties pattern holds here.
two waitlist questions
                        Add optional questions on loneliness and volunteering to the
                        FourthSpace waitlist, to build a first-party measure over time.
foot traffic .......... Test Advan or SafeGraph visit data in the priority tracts. It costs
                        money, so it stays optional.
remote work again ..... Rerun the workday finding with the 2026 ACS once it shows what the
                        return-to-office order did.

TL;DR

studied ............... Where my community app FourthSpace should launch in Sacramento,
                        worked out across seven studies on loneliness.
found ................. Americans 15 and up went from 60.0 minutes a day with friends in
                        2003 to 26.5 in 2025.
  # by the numbers
  26.5 ................ Minutes a day with friends, 2025
  ≈477K ............... Lonely adults in the county, my estimate
  36 .................. Priority tracts
the catch ............. The Sacramento loneliness rates come from a statewide model, so the
                        local counts are estimates built on estimates.
next .................. Ask the California Healthy Kids Survey for Sacramento County results
                        to test the school ties pattern locally.

LINKS

open the full study ... analyst.andrewlengly.com/studies/third-places
the analyst side ...... /machine/analyst

# end of /machine/third-places-casestudy. andrew.leng.ly@gmail.com · leave machine mode